Appleton ties in the MLB playoffs

First, who is out...

Philadelphia:
Greg Dobbs (WI, '02)
Tom Gordon (Foxes, '88)

New York:
Alex Rodriguez (Foxes '94)

Next, who is still in...
Boston:
David Ortiz (WI '96)
Eric Hinske (Menasha, Wisconsin native)

Cleveland:
Asdrubal Cabrera (WI, '05)

Colorado:
Brian Fuentes (WI '98)